The federal judge dismissed the original Republican Party California U.S. Rep. Devin Nunes’s lawsuit against the defamation lawsuit MSNBC host Rachel Madow And NBCUniversal did not take control of the network and acted “actual malicious” when reporting that Nunes refused to take over the package from a licensed Russian agent to the Federal Bureau of Investigation.
Keep up with the latest LGBTQ+News and politics. Sign up for our supporters email newsletter.
Page 24 opinion U.S. District Judge Kevin Castell issued a summary judgment to NBCuniversal, writing that “we have been found to have issued a statement with actual constitutionally defined and malicious intent.”
Nunes, the president’s long-standing ally Donald Trump His CEO Social Media companyafter an episode of , she filed a lawsuit in 2021. Rachel Madou Show A segment on the package addressed to Nunes has been aired Ukrainians Andri Dalkach, a lawmaker. Derkach was announced in 2020 by the US Treasury Department. Russia He is trying to interfere with his agent in the 2020 presidential election.
Related: Rachel Madow sees Americans’ aggressive resistance as the key to overcoming Donald Trump’s strongman game
Madow told viewers that Nunes “refused to hold his hand.” [the package] If you get something from someone who is authorized by the US as a Russian agent, up to the FBI, then this is what you should do.” Politics.
Nunes and his staff members testified that the package was handed over to the FBI the same day they received it, according to court documents. Nunes also wrote to then-chairman William Burr to advise him on the arrival of the package.
The court admitted that Nunes challenged the truth of Madou’s statement, but said that the defamous incident failed to meet the high burden required for public figures. under US Supreme Court Precedent, civil servants must prove that a statement of honor and loss has been made by recklessly ignoring their false knowledge or truth.
“Maddow and Gnazzo both testified that they believe Politics The judge mentioned Maddow and her executive producer Cory Gnazzo, and on July 23, 2020, that the author of the article was well respected, and the author of the article was well respected. Politics Articles they quoted in support of the segment.
The article reported that “people familiar with the matter said the information had not been passed down to the FBI,” and Nunes declined to comment.
“A statement that information was not handed over to the FBI is equivalent to a ‘refusal’,” Castel wrote. “NBCU’s phrasing choices do not deny dependence on Politico’s articles and do not rise to actual maliciousness.”
Related: Rachel Madow says we are “trying to subvert authoritarianly.”
Castel rejected Nunes’ argument that Madou and MSNBC were distorted Politics I reported and ignored other news articles that said the package was properly processed. According to the ruling, Maddow and Gnazzo said they were unaware of follow-up articles citing fellow Republican lawmakers who say Republican lawmakers have been handed over to the FBI.
Nunes also claimed Madou’s long history of criticizing him, identifying 36 episodes she discussed him by name, proving personal bias. However, Castel wrote that “the naked bias claim is insufficient,” and found no evidence that the statement in question was published with “… a highly likely misconception.”
“In the context, Madou’s reference to Nunes as an “easy hit” refers to information about Maloney. This means that there was a package receipt for delivery from Darkach to Nunes. This provided some ready support for the claim.”
Related: Rachel Madow calls MSNBC to center on non-white hosts: “It feels vulnerable.”
The court also addressed NBCUniversal’s request for sanctions against Nunes for alleged spurring evidence. After leaving Congress in early 2022, Nunes did not instruct staff to keep emails or records, according to court documents.
However, as the claims of honor and loss were dismissed, Castel said the court “does not need to sanction Nunes through unfavourable inference or other means due to choking.”
Nunes left home in January 2022 and became CEO of Trump’s social media company Truth Social.
I’ve reached it Supportersrepresentatives from Maddow and MSNBC declined to comment.
Source: Advocate.com – www.advocate.com
